Hillary Campaign Busted: Colombia NAFTA Scandal Brewing

Update-

Remember, just a few weeks ago, one day before the Ohio primary, on March 3, when Senator Clinton - with an assist from Canadian officials - made a mountain out of Canadian press reports that an unpaid economic advisor to Senator Obama had reportedly met with a low-level Canadian diplomat?

Here is what she said:

"If you come to Ohio and you go give speeches that are very critical of NAFTA... and then we find out that your chief economic adviser has gone to a foreign government and basically done the old wink-wink - `Don't pay any attention, this is just political rhetoric' -- I think that raises serious questions...
"I would ask you to look at this story and substitute my name for Sen. Obama's name and see what you would do with this story... Just ask yourself [what you would do] if some of my advisers had been having private meetings with foreign governments."

Now we get to find out.
The Wall Street Journal reports:
Clinton Aide Met on Trade Deal
Penn Held Talks On Colombia Pact Opposed by Senator
By SUSAN DAVIS
April 4, 2008; Page A3
Hillary Clinton's chief campaign strategist met with Colombia's ambassador to the U.S. on Monday to discuss a bilateral free-trade agreement, a pact the presidential candidate opposes.

Attendance by the adviser, Mark Penn, was confirmed by two Colombian officials...
Wait. The plot thickens!

He wasn't there in his campaign role, but in his separate job as chief executive of Burson-Marsteller Worldwide, an international communications and lobbying firm. The firm has a contract with the South American nation to promote congressional approval of the trade deal, among other things, according to filings with the Justice Department...
Penn, Schoen & Berland Associates, Mr. Penn's campaign-consulting firm, received more than $10 million in payments from the Clinton campaign as of the end of February, according to federal election filings...

A spokesman for Colombia's President Álvaro Uribe said the ambassador met with Mr. Penn to discuss the bilateral agenda...

The spokesman said he didn't know if Mr. Penn was representing Sen. Clinton or Burson-Marsteller, which signed a $300,000, one-year contract with the Colombian Embassy in March 2007 to work on behalf of the trade deal and anti-drug-trafficking initiatives, according to the Justice Department filings.
Mark Penn is not - as in the case that Senator Clinton cited on March 3 - an unpaid issues advisor, but, rather, the commander-in-chief of the Clinton campaign: the chief strategist, pollster, message czar, and the highest paid member of her campaign staff.

I can't remember a presidential campaign in my lifetime in which the top strategist moonlighted for corporate accounts during the heat of the primaries. The conflict of interest is staggering. Add to that press reports about how former campaign manager Patty Solis Doyle went to Senator Clinton and begged her to fire Penn, but it was Solis Doyle, not the man in charge, that was cut loose as scapegoat for the campaign's ailments.
Somewhere in Pennsylvania there is a factory that employs Americans at union wages. Somewhere in North Carolina and Indiana, too... The "free trade" agreement that Penn was paid $300,000 to shepherd to passage would open the door for the company that owns the factory to move it to a country where if a worker tries to start a union, chances are he or she will be assassinated. The company will be able to get the same work done, in that case, for slave wages, and without any of those pesky environmental, safety and health regulations that protect the worker in Pennsylvania.

Clinton's March 3 challenge to the press corps - ""I would ask you to look at this story and substitute my name for Sen. Obama's name and see what you would do with this story" - is eerily reminiscent of when a certain Colorado senator running for president in 1988 denied reports about his private life and urged reporters: ""Follow me around. I don't care. I'm serious. If anybody wants to put a tail on me, go ahead. They'll be very bored."

Of course, this scandal doesn't involve sex... just the wellbeing of workers and their families across the United States, with the sword of another dangerous "free trade" agreement dangling over their heads.

Source-http://ruralvotes.com/thefield/?p=998



Display:


Re: Hillary Campaign (none / 0)

Dont you mean BOSNIA BOSNIA BOSNIA.  

I hear it is not NAFTA but is BFTA.

david


by giusd on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 11:05:48 AM EST

Re: Hillary Campaign Busted: Colombia NAFTA Scanda (2.00 / 1)

Let's be fair -- I'm going to take her on her word what she says is her current view of NAFTA.  This shouldn't be so much a problem for Clinton as the far bigger issue that she has Penn on her payroll.


by Rorgg on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 11:19:39 AM EST

Re: Hillary Campaign Busted: Colombia NAFTA Scanda (2.00 / 1)

I agree with the comment above

This is nothing like the NAFTA Gate issue. The Wall Street Journal explicitly says that Penn is acting in a way CONTRARY to how Clinton voted and believed.

More importantly unlike NAFTA gate Penn was NOT representing the campaign as the article also points out explicitly.

Why Mark Penn is doing anything other than running Clinton's campaign is beyond me.


by world dictator on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 11:27:14 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Hillary Campaign Busted: Colombia NAFTA Scanda (none / 0)

Goolsbee wasnt' representing the Obama campaign in Canada. He was there as a professor. Get your facts right. This should be a problem for Clinton but because it's not as interesting as bashing Rev. Wright, the media will ignore it.


by regina1983 on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 12:05:26 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Hillary Campaign Busted: Colombia NAFTA Scanda (none / 0)

"Goolsbee wasnt' representing the Obama campaign in Canada. He was there as a professor."--regina1983

Oh, Oh now I get it, Goolsbee wasn't there walking back Obama's irrational exuberance for ending NAFTA. He was just there as a professor. My, my, is Canada so starved for professors of economics in that entire nation, home to the great Universities of Toronto, McGill and Vancouver, just had to pluck out Mr. Goolsbee from obscurity? Were the Canadians so starved for one professor that they just happened to pick on one Prof. Goolsbee, chief economic advisor to Obama?  Well, I see we were all wrong! Canadian TV, The Prime Minister, the Canadian Ambassador, and everyone at Mydd and anywhere that ever doubted Obama must pay a pilgrimage to Mr. Obama to ask his forgiveness for daring to  pay attention to a written memo from a Canadian government official. As well all know Obama automatically tells the truth. We, along with the Canadians are liars until proven otherwise. C'mon line up, line up, all you unbelivers, Obama doubters and Canadians for absolution from Saint Obama.


by superetendar on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 12:27:11 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Hillary Campaign Busted: Colombia NAFTA Scanda (none / 0)

Nice way to overlook that it was the Canadian Consulate in Chicago that contacted an expert at the University of Chicago for insights.


by Rorgg on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 03:54:16 PM EST
[ Parent ]

That Mark Penn really gets around (none / 0)

doesn't he?  Your money well spent, Clinton supporters?


by ReillyDiefenbach on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 03:15:26 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Hah ha Penn is such a doofus. (none / 0)

Do you Hillary fans even like him anymore?


by DSloth on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 11:25:28 AM EST

Mark Penn is a disgusting person (none / 0)

And the fact that he has been kept on the campaign payroll for so long tells me all I need to know about the Clinton's willingness to tolerate these kind of people for the marginal political benefit.


by highgrade on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 11:30:36 AM EST

Re: Mark Penn is a disgusting person (none / 0)

He is the new Mike Brownie

and the guy looks creapy as hell.


My dream is Hillary will sponser a joint resolution to authorize the use of the United States Armed Forces against Trinity Church
by denounceandreject on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 11:32:56 AM EST
[ Parent ]

non story (2.00 / 1)

This is ridiculous.  Penn wasn't representing her.
Goolsby was representing Obama.
Don't think the blue collar people of Pennsylvania understand the difference?  Think again.

This is a non-story, Kathy.

I hardly think BO is in a position to raise this issue...it would backfire.


TexasDarlin blog
by TexasDarlin on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 11:35:55 AM EST

Re: non story (none / 0)

I think that's a mistake. Goulsbee was not representing Obama. He was approached by the Canadian consul that wanted more information on Obama.
It was not a campaign activity, Goulsbee (as per the Cnadian memo) stipulated that he was no expert on NAFTA and during the meeting Goulsbee repeated the basic stance of Obama.
So, if senator Clinton describes that meeting as Obama doing the nudge nudge, wink wink routine, I'm very interested in how she would describe it when her chief strategist taking money from another goverment to get a new free trade deal accepted.
by hebi on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 11:50:36 AM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: non story (none / 0)

TD - I think it is important to point out that an Goolsby is unpaid issues advisor...Penn is raking in 10 million+ and considered to be #1 or #2 in the Clinton campaign.

Apples and Oranges here.

Besides the fact that what Penn is doing is not unclear. His role is to SPIN a trade agreement that Clinton says she opposes.


We don't need a thinker. We need a doer: someone who'll act without considering the consequences. (H.J. Simpson)
by Newcomer on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 01:52:19 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Hillary Campaign Busted: Colombia NAFTA Scanda (2.00 / 1)

Do we really want to get into a discussion about who has lobbyists working for them? Contrary to what Obama is telling you folks his staff is crawling with them.


by Iceblinkjm on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 11:38:58 AM EST

Really? (none / 0)

Please start listing those lobbyists who have ties to human rights violators.


by regina1983 on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 12:06:34 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Colombia NAFTA (none / 0)

Oh yeah, sure.  Penn wasn't representing the Clinton campaign, representing a Business, but this is your breaking news of the Clinton campaign?   WOW...hold me back.   Do you REALLY want us to start going through all of Obama's advisors and aides backgrounds???? NO  lol  you don't.  Let's just stick with the issues that matter.......

....you know, like how we keep hearing Obama's campaign talk are just political rhetoric?  The last one was that his pledge to end occupation in his Presidential campaign was just talk, "he would instead go with a plan crafted as president, no one he was using in his campaign".

...and now it seems it's correct.  His CAMPAIGN ADVISOR in a secret memo that he is PLANNING to keep 60-80,000 troops in Iraq through 2010.

"The paper, obtained by The New York Sun, was written by Colin Kahl for the center-left Center for a New American Security. In “Stay on Success: A Policy of Conditional Engagement,” Mr. Kahl writes that through negotiations with the Iraqi government “the U.S. should aim to transition to a sustainable over-watch posture (of perhaps 60,000–80,000 forces) by the end of 2010 (although the specific timelines should be the byproduct of negotiations and conditions on the ground).”

Mr. Kahl is the day-to-day coordinator of the Obama campaign’s working group on Iraq. A shorter and less detailed version of this paper appeared on the center’s Web site as a policy brief."


by LindaSFNM on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 12:15:35 PM EST

Re: Hillary Campaign Busted: (none / 0)

The Iraq paper is a problem for Obama - he will doubtless say that this is not his position, but he welcomes an exchange of ideas among his advisors etc.  Certainly not an issue that he wants right now.  

But, COME ON!, for the Clinton supporters here to say that 'chief strategist' Penn attending a meeting to push CAFTA is not a problem for HRC is patently ridiculous.  How did the 'acting in a private capacity' argument re Goolsbee work out for Obama in Ohio?  It is a problem, and potentially a big problem, particularly among union voters in PA and, to a lesser extent, Indiana.  


by Kensingtonbill on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 12:25:36 PM EST

Obama's Minority Report Movie (none / 0)

Mark Penn now offering Hillary Clinton economic advice like Obama's Economic Advisor, Austan Goolsbee? I thought Gene Sperling was Hillary Clinton's economic advisor. Was Sperling at that meeting with the Columbians too? Because that's the only way I see this story as being relevant.

God knows, I can't stand Mark Penn but is this story fair? While we are on a purity drive can we get clarification on the role of Tom Daschle, Obama's campaign co-chair who is also a major lobbyist. Are we 100 percent sure Daschle has not spoken to clients in the past months? Will we have to check Daschle's "secret" phone calls?

This is like that movie Minority Report where we automatically assign malice of forethought and bad intentions and motives on mere psychic evidence.


by superetendar on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 12:37:06 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama's Minority Report Movie (none / 0)

Please tell me that you see the point here.
Penn is getting paid 10+ million dollars buy HRC...he is taking millions of dollars from Colombia to spin a trade deal. In one hand he has millions of dollars to help spin HRC on issues (like trade!) and in the other hand he has millions to help spin a trade deal that his candidate opposes.

No conflict of interest?


We don't need a thinker. We need a doer: someone who'll act without considering the consequences. (H.J. Simpson)
by Newcomer on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 01:45:16 PM EST
[ Parent ]

Re: Obama's Minority Report Movie (none / 0)

Wow...I just realized that you are throwing mud at a distinguished former democratic senator...is this what we have become.

Remember - Penn's firm also gets paid by McCain. (I wont even go into the conflict of interest theories here...)

This guy BETTER not be anywhere near the White House if HRC is president.


We don't need a thinker. We need a doer: someone who'll act without considering the consequences. (H.J. Simpson)
by Newcomer on Fri Apr 04, 2008 at 01:47:08 PM EST
[ Parent ]


You are not logged in.

In order to post a comment, you must be logged in. If you have a member account, please log in to comment.

If not, you can make an account right here. It's quick and free.